Should You Get a Prenup? How Legal Planning Can Strengthen (Not Sabotage) Your Marriage
Should You Get a Prenup? How Legal Planning Can Strengthen (Not Sabotage) Your Marriage
📝 Episode Description:
Prenuptial agreements aren’t just for the rich and famous—they’re a powerful tool for protecting your marriage and your peace of mind. In this episode of Doing Life Different, attorney Melissa Miroslavich breaks down what a prenup is, why more couples should consider one, and how legal planning can actually reduce the chance of divorce.
Whether you're getting married, remarried, or just want to understand what you're committing to legally, this conversation will change the way you see prenuptial agreements. We also explore the emerging role of postnuptial agreements and the power of collaborative law to create respectful resolutions—even when emotions run high.
Melissa shares how couples can use prenups to clarify their financial values, communicate more openly, and avoid costly legal battles down the road. This episode is especially valuable if you're navigating divorce, thinking about marriage, or want to set your relationship up for long-term success.
⏱️ Timestamps:
(00:00) Quick intro: Why this turned into a two-part series
(01:10) Meet Melissa Miroslavich and her path to collaborative law
(04:42) What is collaborative law and why it matters
(08:00) How collaborative divorce protects families and kids
(11:33) The value of financial neutrals and family specialists
(14:25) What is a postnup? And how does it help married couples?
(15:10) Introduction to prenuptial agreements
(18:00) Why prenups are misunderstood—and how they strengthen marriage
(22:01) Financial transparency and setting expectations
(25:32) Are prenups enforceable in every state?
(27:50) Can prenups be challenged in court?
(32:05) Melissa’s advice for using prenups to reduce divorce conflict
(36:40) Why prenups are more about communication than control
(40:12) Final thoughts: Empowerment through legal clarity
âś… Key Takeaways:
- A prenuptial agreement is a proactive tool—not a predictor of divorce
- Collaborative law focuses on family-first solutions, not courtroom battles
- Postnups can help already-married couples clarify finances and avoid conflict
- Legal planning in advance helps reduce emotional and financial strain later
- Prenups promote financial transparency, communication, and mutual respect
👩‍⚖️ Guest Bio:
Melissa Miroslavich is a Minnesota-based attorney specializing in collaborative law, prenuptial/postnuptial agreements, and estate planning. With a background in business and a passion for client-centered solutions, Melissa helps families navigate legal planning with empathy and integrity. She serves on the board of the Collaborative Law Institute of Minnesota and is dedicated to helping couples resolve issues without unnecessary conflict.
đź”— Resource Links:
- Melissa’s Website: https://www.miroslavichlaw.com/
- Collaborative Law Institute of Minnesota: https://www.collaborativelaw.org
- Find a Collaborative Attorney (IACP): https://www.collaborativepractice.com
🏷️ Tags/Keywords:
prenuptial agreement, postnuptial agreement, collaborative law, how to stay married, divorce prevention, legal planning for marriage, marriage and money, estate planning, women over 40, relationship advice, how to not get divorced, co-parenting, family law, peaceful divorce, conflict resolution, Lesa Koski podcast
Transcript
Welcome to this week's episode of Doing Divorce Different.
2
:I wanted to get in here quick and let
you know that my conversation with
3
:today's guest, Melissa Miro, Slavic,
turned in to a two-part series.
4
:It's really, really good.
5
:It's helpful if you are.
6
:Thinking about divorce or if
you're wanting to not get divorced,
7
:for both of those reasons today
we're gonna talk about prenups.
8
:So this is where it matters for you.
9
:No matter where you are in your
life, if you've never been married,
10
:she talks through a prenup and
how it can really help you.
11
:I learned that.
12
:I really strongly agree with them.
13
:And then in next week's
episode, we're gonna talk about.
14
:Post-op.
15
:So that's something that you do when
you're already married, um, to decide
16
:what you're gonna do with your finances.
17
:And I learned a lot and there's lots
of really good reasons to have those.
18
:So stay tuned for that as well.
19
:And I'm glad that you're here today.
20
:Speaker: Welcome listeners.
21
:I am very excited that you're here
today because we have Melissa Merril
22
:Slavic, and she's an attorney.
23
:She was on a long time ago, and
the main thing we're gonna talk
24
:about today are postnuptial and
collaborative postnup and how sometimes.
25
:They're used in divorce and
sometimes they keep you married.
26
:So I'm super excited because
Melissa really focuses on this.
27
:She does a lot in collaborative law.
28
:Um, she's gonna kinda share her
career journey a little bit because
29
:I said I'm so excited for her.
30
:She has an attorney, she's off on her own.
31
:And Melissa, I know that that's not easy.
32
:So I think our listeners would
love to get to know you better.
33
:And so if you wouldn't mind
just sharing what led you down
34
:this path and how you ended up.
35
:Break it off on your own.
36
:Speaker 2: Sure.
37
:Happy to talk about it, and I'm
very, very happy to be here.
38
:Thanks for having me back.
39
:I, um, I actually became an attorney as
a second career, so I, um, started out my
40
:attorney life kind of in a different way.
41
:I had a whole bunch of experience in, um.
42
:Entirely different business.
43
:I was a business owner
before I went to law school.
44
:And when I was in law school I was
introduced to collaborative law, which
45
:might feel a little bit like an oxymoron.
46
:Yeah.
47
:The trained attorneys, uh, we
tend to look at the adjudicative
48
:process as a tit for tat.
49
:Who's gonna win, who's gonna lose?
50
:There's negotiation in things.
51
:Like that.
52
:But the collaborative law process
overlay was really interesting to me
53
:because I feel like it trains attorneys
on how to put the family's goals first.
54
:Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.
55
:Speaker 2: And take the family's
interests and how they might want a
56
:divorce process to go for an example,
what that process should look like.
57
:And overlays that and sort of removes the
court from the process while everybody
58
:still has an advocate on their side to
help them through the legal process.
59
:So that was my introduction
to collaborative law.
60
:And then when I left, uh, became an
attorney and left the school, I um,
61
:I started working in family law.
62
:Quickly joined the Collaborative Law
Institute and I'm on the board there.
63
:So full disclosure,
that's really important
64
:Speaker 3: to me.
65
:Speaker 2: And I also do estate planning.
66
:And, um, through a series of working
at a couple of different firms, I
67
:realized that the way that I wanna
serve clients is much more like my
68
:previous career in client service.
69
:And so I'm now able to overlay
those two things together.
70
:I can work with clients the way I want
to service clients, and then I can also
71
:do this in a collaborative way and be
really, um, a proactive problem solver.
72
:For people versus a
reactive problem solver.
73
:So that's why I'm here doing what I do.
74
:Speaker: I love that, Melissa.
75
:And it's so fun because I just
had two, um, female attorneys from
76
:New York and the interview did
not go like how I had expected.
77
:They were not collaborative
law attorneys, but like you,
78
:they cared about the families.
79
:I'm like, this is the whole new.
80
:This is the what I dreamed about.
81
:You know what I mean?
82
:And I love that you learned about
collaborative law in law school.
83
:I, I too went after starting a career.
84
:I'm a little more mature than you.
85
:And so when I went, um, I wasn't
hearing a lot about collaborative law.
86
:I heard a little bit about mediation.
87
:Um, and I jumped in.
88
:I did some, a state law when my
kids were babies and just 'cause
89
:it seemed like it was simpler, but
it wasn't really a good fit for me.
90
:Um, and as I kept searching for what was a
good fit, I realized I didn't wanna fight.
91
:I wanted to help people
communicate and work together.
92
:And I think we do have some new
attorneys coming out with this
93
:thought process and, you know.
94
:I love it because it's giving us a
better name because, and I have dealt
95
:with some attorneys who wanna just
keep the fire burning 'cause they're
96
:making money and I don't like that.
97
:I don't like that at all.
98
:So I love that we have
this, these people here.
99
:There's you helping people work together.
100
:Why make it worse in
your head emotionally?
101
:Financially, you know, I,
102
:Speaker 2: I totally agree with that
and I'll say, um, I'm a little bit
103
:lucky because I live in Minnesota
and that's where my license is,
104
:and Minnesota is literally the
birthplace of collaborative law.
105
:It was created in the nineties
and from there it became this
106
:international phenomenon.
107
:There's an international group
called the IACP, and it's now in lots
108
:and lots of different states and I
think it's getting more traction.
109
:Um, and there are some states who
have embraced it wholeheartedly
110
:and actually use this.
111
:Um, approach and other types
of law, not just family law.
112
:So I do think that the, the
world is sort of ripe for
113
:another way to resolve conflict.
114
:I so
115
:Speaker: agree.
116
:Yeah.
117
:Yeah.
118
:Speaker 2: There are people who are
stepping up to the plate, um, and
119
:still wanna do it in a way where we
can protect people and also protect
120
:sort of the outcome when, because when
you're married, especially with kids.
121
:Whether you're divorced or not, or
you've created two households and
122
:you know, you don't just have one
anymore, you're in each other's lives.
123
:Mm-hmm.
124
:And we have to figure
out ways to communicate.
125
:And the process you choose to get to
the final divorce decree, for example,
126
:is really important because I think
it affects how you communicate later.
127
:Yeah.
128
:And what's nice about collaborative
law and why it will, I'll mention
129
:this too when we talk about the
postnuptial agreements, but we also
130
:can use other resources that I think
mediators are very familiar with, but.
131
:I can pull in professionals who
are financial neutrals, who are
132
:trained mediators themselves, they're
financial planners, and they also
133
:understand and have been trained
in the collaborative process.
134
:Mm-hmm.
135
:So they understand how
to support the process.
136
:Same with family specialists as well.
137
:So we can pull on folks like that,
who can help us sort of build
138
:everybody up for the next step.
139
:Speaker: Right.
140
:And I just have to add, I love
the piece where you help kids.
141
:In collaborative law, you can, you know,
I know there's lots of great therapists.
142
:Brian Burns has been on this podcast.
143
:I use him, um, when a kid's, you
know, when we're struggling to find
144
:out what that kid really wants.
145
:Speaker 3: Yeah.
146
:Speaker: Um, you know, so there's some, so
it's, it's just such a, a special thing.
147
:And I think in New York, um, I
don't think collaborative law
148
:is what it is in Minnesota.
149
:So if you're there.
150
:You know, check out the ladies
that were on last week and
151
:'cause they'll be helpful.
152
:But, um, if you're in Minnesota.
153
:You know, reach out to Melissa, reach
out to someone from the Collaborative
154
:Law Institute because it is a great
way to do it if you can work together.
155
:So, okay, so now we've like done our
little plug for collaborative law.
156
:And I'm not even really part of it,
but it's just in my realm, in my,
157
:it's, it's, um, I wanna talk about,
well, let's just, let's start out,
158
:some people might be, what's a postnup?
159
:What is that?
160
:Speaker 2: So I'm gonna say the, the
alpha world prenuptial agreement first.
161
:Speaker: Oh, let's talk about that.
162
:Speaker 2: Easier to understand a
postnuptial agreement if we understand
163
:what a prenuptial agreement is, right?
164
:Mm-hmm.
165
:So, um, so a prenuptial agreement you
probably more likely heard of, but a
166
:prenuptial agreement is before you get
married, you get to make decisions about
167
:if you want to do something different than
the law would do in the case of divorce.
168
:End or death, which are
the two ways marriages end.
169
:Right?
170
:Speaker: Yeah.
171
:Speaker 2: A post-nuptial agreement
is a similar concept except you
172
:are already married, so we can put
together an agreement that would look
173
:similar to a prenuptial agreement,
but you're already married, so we
174
:don't have the prenuptial part of it.
175
:We have the post-nuptial part of it.
176
:Speaker: Okay.
177
:I didn't think I was gonna do this, so
we don't have to go here, but can we
178
:talk a little bit more about prenups?
179
:Yes.
180
:Because I'm.
181
:It's interesting, Melissa.
182
:I have like so many young women, like
if I go to a baby shower and they're
183
:like, oh, you do that podcast about
divorce, how do I not get divorced?
184
:Or, what do you think about this?
185
:Can you just talk a little bit about a
prenup and how that can be really good?
186
:Yes.
187
:For your marriage, when you, when you
are deciding to get married, would you
188
:mind, I'm sorry, I didn't tell you.
189
:I
190
:Speaker 2: do prenups and post.
191
:Um, as well as estate planning.
192
:This is sort of like all
preventative problem solving, right?
193
:Speaker: Yes.
194
:Yes.
195
:Speaker 2: So, um, here's the thing
about prenuptial agreements, which
196
:I think is super interesting, is
a lot of people think it's sort of
197
:the precursor to divorce, right?
198
:Like, ooh, we're planning for a
divorce before we even get married.
199
:Yeah, and it sounds really awful.
200
:I would argue that it's actually a really
important tool that will strengthen
201
:your marriage because you go in with
eyes wide open and here's the thing.
202
:When you're getting married, at least
in Minnesota, it doesn't take a lot.
203
:You have to be 18.
204
:Mm-hmm.
205
:Speaker 3: And you have
206
:Speaker 2: to be not married.
207
:And then you get to sign on the
dotted line, which is great.
208
:When you sign on the dotted
line, these things called spousal
209
:rights get put into place.
210
:And those spousal rights, if
you don't understand what they
211
:are, that can be really shocking
if you end up getting divorced.
212
:Speaker: Okay.
213
:Melissa, I'm gonna jump in
because I just had this Aha.
214
:When you were talking about this, I almost
felt like everybody should, should do one.
215
:Everybody should do.
216
:You wanna know why?
217
:Because so many people come to me and
they're, they're needing to get divorced.
218
:They wanna do it together.
219
:And they're like, well, can't
we just like, we don't care.
220
:Like who?
221
:And I'm like.
222
:No, you are in a legally binding
committed partnership and people
223
:don't even understand that.
224
:Yeah.
225
:They have no idea that their business
or, you know, they have no idea.
226
:They're like, well, this
is how we wanna do it.
227
:Well, we can probably get you to where
you wanna go, but this is a legal,
228
:you know, we gotta go through this.
229
:And if they have it set up,
they're gonna be more aware.
230
:This is a big deal.
231
:This is a big commitment.
232
:It's not only a big commitment
for you, it's a huge commitment
233
:as a partnership, as a business.
234
:Speaker 2: Yes.
235
:And you don't need the court
to, uh, to get married.
236
:You sign and you have a, a witness.
237
:Yes.
238
:But like, you need a
judge to get divorced.
239
:Right.
240
:At least in Minnesota.
241
:I'm not gonna speak to the
whole country, but Right.
242
:Every state has their own laws about
how this works, especially with
243
:prenuptial and postnuptial agreements,
not all states will honor them.
244
:Um, so it kind of depends on the
state that you're in as well.
245
:But yeah, you, you need
a judge to sign off on.
246
:A divorce and they're gonna look at the
division of your assets, and all of a
247
:sudden we have this huge learning curve
about what does division of assets mean?
248
:What kind of assets get divided?
249
:So when I'm doing prenuptial
agreements, I really think about
250
:it more as a marital estate plan.
251
:It's a, it's basically a way
to have a conversation about
252
:finances and you get to make.
253
:I guess really important
conversations take place about
254
:how do we want our money to flow?
255
:Are we gonna be really separate?
256
:Are we gonna join things?
257
:Are we joining everything?
258
:And what does that look like?
259
:And then if a divorce were to happen.
260
:How is that then cha, how does that
change how this property is understood
261
:and how it gets divided, essentially.
262
:But I think it's much better, and
obviously I'm biased, but going in,
263
:knowing what that could look like.
264
:And some people feel very differently
when a marriage ends with a divorce
265
:versus when a marriage ends with in death.
266
:Right.
267
:And so you can handle those two
points in time differently, and you
268
:can do that while you love each other
while you're making good decisions.
269
:Yeah.
270
:And you can also have really good
conversations before you get married to
271
:make sure that if you have differences
of opinion, you talk about it and
272
:you sort of have a plan for that.
273
:Speaker: I, I think that is, that's
what I find to be the most helpful
274
:piece of it, is that you're really
understanding what you're getting into.
275
:And we don't, I didn't, I went
through a church thing that
276
:helped, but I didn't go through.
277
:Understanding the financial aspect, you
really need to under, I mean, you wouldn't
278
:go just into a, well, maybe some people go
into business with someone without, but I
279
:wouldn't, you know, and so I, and I, yeah.
280
:I don't see it as even leading to divorce.
281
:I see it.
282
:And, and here's another thing, Melissa,
I was thinking about when you are
283
:getting divorced, emotions are high
and it's really hard to use that
284
:prodigy brain to come to decisions.
285
:If you can talk about it, when you're
in a good place, when you're using
286
:your brain and you're not under
stress and you have it kind of all
287
:you, it makes it so much simpler and
you hope that you don't get there.
288
:You, I mean, I wonder, I would
love to see couples who sit
289
:down together and do a prenup.
290
:I would love to see if they
get divorced more or less.
291
:Speaker 2: It would be really interesting.
292
:I don't have any stats
on that, but if we can,
293
:Speaker: how can we, well, let's do it.
294
:Speaker 2: Think of something so.
295
:A lot of times when I'm doing
prenuptial agreements, it's not like
296
:we're really, um, doing something
that's like, oh, this is super
297
:different than what the law would say.
298
:But it also does something
that's important that helps
299
:you stamp something in time.
300
:And you probably on this podcast
talk about marital property
301
:and non-marital property.
302
:So that's a concept if you're
not familiar with it a little.
303
:Yeah.
304
:Um, is, um.
305
:There's certain kinds of property that
gets divided and certain that doesn't.
306
:And so instead of having a fight later
about what is and what isn't gonna be
307
:divided, you get to decide that upfront.
308
:Mm-hmm.
309
:And so people who are bringing
things to the marriage, maybe it's,
310
:um, they already have a business or
each, each spouse has a, a home, or
311
:they've already been married before.
312
:They're bringing things, history, life
experience to the marriage, and we can
313
:kind of put a stamp in time that says,
Hey, this is what's happening now.
314
:So that if something changes in the
future and we look back, we've already
315
:established a foundation or a baseline
that people can fight about and this
316
:helps take the fight out of it, and
I think it makes it less contentious.
317
:And it makes it, um, less costly.
318
:Mm-hmm.
319
:Because the first thing an attorney
asks, when you're getting, when you
320
:talk to a divorce attorney, if you're,
if you're looking at divorces, do
321
:you have a prenuptial agreement?
322
:The second question is gonna be,
do we wanna try to invalidate it?
323
:Do we wanna enforce it?
324
:Like, where are you at?
325
:And I will tell you many, many
times when I was doing this type
326
:of work, clients would say to me,
this is the agreement we wa we made.
327
:I'm gonna honor it.
328
:Let's just move forward.
329
:And we've hurdled and skipped a whole
bunch of steps that cause a lot of, um,
330
:contention and fighting that can do that
and, and adds to that sort of levity
331
:and inability to process information
because you're emotional about things.
332
:Yep.
333
:And so I think it helps.
334
:Smooth.
335
:I mean, the intent really is
to help smooth those processes
336
:down and let, let them be less
intense when emotions are running
337
:Speaker: high.
338
:Right.
339
:Okay.
340
:I have to ask you a couple
questions that popped up.
341
:You said that this is true
in the state of Minnesota.
342
:This podcast is not just
in the state of Minnesota.
343
:So what if people are listening to this
and they're like, okay, I live in Maine.
344
:I live in, you know, I
don't know if this applies.
345
:How can they, what's an easy way for them?
346
:Do they just, I mean, I guess we just
Google everything now, but what's a
347
:good way for them to know if there
are pre and postnup in their state?
348
:I almost feel like I should get a list.
349
:Speaker 2: Yeah, maybe we
could put a list together.
350
:Um, what I would do is, um, I would
either talk to an attorney, usually an
351
:estate planning attorney or a family law
attorney would be the place you would
352
:start to know if it's even an option
for you in the state that you live in.
353
:You can also look up your state statutes.
354
:Um, I will say prenup.
355
:We call them prenuptial agreements.
356
:I don't
357
:Speaker: even wanna read the
statute and I'm an attorney
358
:Speaker 2: know if it's there.
359
:Right, exactly.
360
:Um, is there one and how handled?
361
:Um, and I'll say in Minnesota, they're
actually not called pre, we call them
362
:prenuptial agreements, but they're
actually called antinuptial agreements.
363
:Okay.
364
:I didn't even, yeah, yeah.
365
:So A NTE nuptial Okay.
366
:Is what they're actually called.
367
:So, um, but yeah, I would, I
would, I would probably do a search
368
:and say, Hey, is this viable?
369
:Is this something that I can do?
370
:Speaker: And then I have to ask
you something else because, and you
371
:mentioned this, that the first question
attorneys ask, do you have a prenup?
372
:And then the second question
is, do you want to stand by
373
:it or do you wanna fight it?
374
:And I have heard, and this,
they kinda get a bad rap.
375
:They do because people fight 'em.
376
:And how successful are they
and how often are they fought?
377
:So you put this beautiful
thing together and then.
378
:Then you're gonna pay
more to fight about it.
379
:That's what people are maybe thinking.
380
:Speaker 2: Got it.
381
:Um, so here's what I'll say
is the thing about the law is
382
:there's no black and white.
383
:There just isn't.
384
:Mm-hmm.
385
:And so if you're going to fight a
prenuptial agreement, chances are
386
:you are gonna fight anyway because
the things that are in the prenuptial
387
:agreement, what you're basically
doing is you're helping yourself, um.
388
:Say, this is where we were at.
389
:This is why it's important, and that's
one of the reasons why I really encourage
390
:people with prenuptial agreements.
391
:And postal agreements in Minnesota
are required that you both have
392
:an attorney because you want the
prenup to be as strong as possible.
393
:You wanna understand your rights, you
wanna understand what the provisions mean.
394
:You wanna make sure things that are
in there are allowed to be in there.
395
:And then it's really a contract.
396
:So it's it al almost is like, are
we gonna evaluate this contract?
397
:Now?
398
:My experience is people tend to
honor the prenuptial agreement.
399
:I'm sure that there would be litigators
who tell you that that is not the case.
400
:So my world tends to be mm-hmm.
401
:People who are planners and are
trying to be great to each other
402
:and know that they want their kids
to have the best parents they can.
403
:And so I think people who work with
me tend to want to be more mm-hmm.
404
:Collaborative.
405
:I'll say that in a, like a small
c sort of way, like mm-hmm.
406
:Um, so my, my bias is probably
presenting itself very clearly here.
407
:But I do think it helps you at least
state in a moment in time, this is
408
:what we came to the marriage with.
409
:And that is one of the questions
that that gets asked whether you
410
:have a prenuptial agreement or not.
411
:Speaker: Mm-hmm.
412
:What
413
:Speaker 2: come to the
marriage with, right,
414
:Speaker: right.
415
:Speaker 2: And now we're
saying, here's what it is.
416
:Not only that, but here's the
exhibits, here's the full disclosure.
417
:Here's, there's no
fraud, there's no duress.
418
:And when a prenuptial agreement is fought,
there's typically provisions that say,
419
:well, if you take out this one little
section or this one little section didn't
420
:work, the rest of it's still valid.
421
:You're still minimizing as much as
possible and setting yourself up
422
:for success to have less arguments.
423
:Speaker: Gotcha.
424
:Okay.
425
:That's helpful.
426
:I, yeah, I see it.
427
:Overall as a great, great tool that
I'm gonna recommend a lot more,
428
:I think, than I have, have been.
429
:Speaker 2: It's a really good tool
for strengthening your marriage.
430
:I
431
:Speaker: think so.
432
:And understanding what
you're getting into.